Key takeaways
- Listed paid entry prices run from EUR 29 a month (Otterly.AI Lite) to $295 (AthenaHQ Starter, Goodie Core). Profound now offers only a free trial and custom Enterprise plans.
- Starting prices are not comparable on their own: prompts, engines and credits differ by plan, so check that your buyers' assistants are on the plan you can afford.
- Seven of the nine offer a free trial or a free tier. Semrush says it has no trial, and Ahrefs states none but offers a free visibility check.
- These tools measure. Some draft fixes for your own site, but none of the pages we read describes posting in the Reddit threads AI answers cite.
- Pair a tracker for the score with work on the sources, and keep a fixed monthly prompt panel to tell your changes from the assistants' own.
01How we compared the tools
We read each vendor's own pricing and product pages on November 18, 2026, and compared the nine tools on five things: what they measure, which AI engines they cover, the starting price exactly as listed, whether there is a free trial, and whether they only measure or also act.
We did not buy every plan or run the same prompts through each tool, so this guide does not score accuracy. Everything below is what the vendors publish, quoted where it matters. Prices change and can display differently by region: Ahrefs showed EUR 47 and EUR 179 on November 17 and $50 and $199 on November 18. Otterly.AI's live pricing page did not load for us, so its price comes from a November 17, 2026 capture of that page.
- Measures: mentions, position, sentiment, share of voice, sources.
- Engines: what the entry plan covers, not the top plan.
- Price: the lowest listed paid plan and what it includes.
- Trial: a free trial, a free tier or neither.
- Measure or act: does it only report, or also draft or change something?
02The nine AI visibility tools at a glance
Here are the nine tools side by side, with each starting price as the vendor listed it on November 18, 2026, and the engines the vendor names.
Read the price with the prompt count next to it. A 16-prompt plan and a 500-prompt plan are different products, and a prompt does not mean the same thing everywhere: Profound's trial runs 50 prompts daily, while AthenaHQ sells credits.
AI visibility tools compared
What each tool measures, the engines it names, whether you can try it free, and its starting price as listed.
| What is compared | What it measures | Engines (per vendor) | Free trial | Starting price as listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Profound | Visibility in answer engines, plus AI Marketer agents | Trial: ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Overviews. Enterprise: up to 10 | Yes: 50 prompts daily for 7 days | Trial free; Enterprise custom |
| Peec AI | Visibility, position, sentiment, sources | Starter: choose 3 of ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini and others | Yes, length not stated | $95/mo billed monthly, 50 prompts |
| Otterly.AI | Mentions and citations, plus 3 recommendations a week | ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude. Lite: 4 of 7 | Yes, length not stated | EUR 29/mo, 16 prompts (Nov 17 capture) |
| Scrunch | Prompt and topic tracking, citations, AI bot traffic | Core: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Copilot | Yes, 7 days | $250/mo, 125 prompts |
| AthenaHQ | Visibility, share of voice, cited sites, plus a content agent | Starter: 11 models incl. ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok | No trial; free Essential tier (300 credits) | $295/mo Starter (page also shows $300) |
| Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | AI Visibility Score, share of voice, sentiment, prompt tracking | Prompt tracking: Google AI Mode, ChatGPT | No | $99/mo, 25 prompts |
| Ahrefs Brand Radar | Mentions, share of voice, cited sources including Reddit | AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot; Claude on the Index plan | None stated; free visibility check | $50/mo custom prompts; $199/mo Index |
| LLMrefs | Rankings, share of voice, citations, content gaps | ChatGPT, ChatGPT Search, AI Overviews, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Grok, Copilot | Yes, 7 days | $79/mo, 500 prompts (limited time) |
| Goodie | Visibility analytics plus optimization recommendations | 5 core models on Core | Yes, 7 days | $295/mo, 110 prompts |
- AI visibility tools compared, from vendor pages read November 18, 2026
- 9
- Offer a free trial or a free tier
- 7 of 9
- Describe posting in the Reddit threads AI answers cite
- 0 of 9
Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.
03Which AI visibility tool fits which team?
Pick by the team you already are: suite users should start with Semrush or Ahrefs, small teams on a budget with Otterly.AI, LLMrefs or Peec AI, and larger teams that want agents or optimization work bundled in with Profound, Scrunch, AthenaHQ or Goodie.
Profound fits large brands that want monitoring plus AI Marketer agents that do marketing work, across up to 10 answer engines on Enterprise. Its FAQ says it retired the Starter and Growth plans for brands in September 2026, so the choice now is the free trial or a custom-priced Enterprise plan.
Peec AI fits marketing teams that want clear analytics at a published price, with Pro at $245 and Advanced at $495 above the $95 Starter and 15% off annual billing. It mostly measures and gives guidance; one of its product mock-ups suggests joining a subreddit discussion.
Otterly.AI is the cheapest way in, and the vendor says every plan includes unlimited brands, competitors, countries and team members. Lite covers 4 of its 7 engines, so choose them carefully. It adds three recommendations a week.
Scrunch fits teams that also care about how AI agents read their website: its Agent Experience Platform, on Enterprise, serves pages built for AI agents. Its marketing names Claude and Gemini, but Core lists four engines, so confirm what your plan includes.
AthenaHQ fits teams that want a free start and a long list of engines. Starter also appears as $300 on the same page, with 17% off annual. It lists a content optimization agent and "on-page and off-page actions".
Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit fits teams already paying for Semrush. Extra prompts cost $60 a month per 50, and it adds AI recommendations and an AI Search Health site audit. Semrush says plainly: "No, the AI Visibility Toolkit does not offer a free trial."
Ahrefs Brand Radar fits teams that want a large prompt database instead of writing every prompt: it checks visibility "across 500M+ prompts from 6 AI tools". It tracks Reddit as a source and does not act on it.
LLMrefs fits small teams that want many prompts on one plan: 500 for $79 a month, marked "Limited time only". It lists cited sources and content gaps.
Goodie fits teams that want optimization work bundled with tracking: Core includes "MCP + 50 optimizations / mo", and Pro is $999.
04AI visibility tools measure the answers. They do not change the sources.
An AI visibility tool tells you how often assistants name you and which pages they cite; it does not change what those pages say, and those pages are what the answers are written from.
A tracker runs your prompts, reads the answers and reports the mentions and sources. That is useful, and it stops there: the review sites, videos and Reddit threads that keep appearing are not something a tracker can edit.
Reddit is a large share of those sources. Peec AI's own study of 30 million sources across ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity and AI Overviews in the US (published March 2026) ranks Reddit first. Among the nine tools, Ahrefs Brand Radar tracks Reddit as a source and a Peec AI mock-up suggests joining a subreddit discussion. None of the pages we read describes posting in those threads.
So the tools cover one half of the job. Several help with your own site: Profound's AI Marketer agents, Scrunch's pages for AI agents, AthenaHQ's content optimization agent and Goodie's monthly optimizations. AthenaHQ also lists "on-page and off-page actions", but its page does not describe posting on Reddit. Taking part in the third-party conversations that AI reads is left to you.
best running shoes for flat feet under $150
AI assistant
Runners on Reddit recommend a stability shoe with a firm medial post. For flat feet under $150, the Velka Glide 2 ($129) comes up often, along with swapping the insoles early.
Sources · 5
- Flat feet, 30 miles a week. Which shoes under $150 actually last?reddit.com · r/running
- Stability shoes that survive 400 miles?reddit.com · r/RunningShoeGeeks
- Best stability shoes this year, testedyoutube.com
- Wide toe box options for flat feetreddit.com · r/trailrunning
- The best running shoes of the yearRunning magazine
Sample accounts and posts, made up for this page.
05Octosift is not a tracker. It works on the Reddit sources.
Octosift is not an AI visibility tracker: it does not measure share of voice, and it works on one kind of source, the Reddit threads that rank on Google and get cited in AI answers, which is why it is not in the comparison above.
For your buyers' questions, it checks which Reddit threads Google ranks and AI assistants cite, sets aside the ones that are locked or whose rules forbid what you could say, and answers the open ones in your voice from your own accounts. Whenever a reply names your product, it says who is writing. It also reads your communities for new questions every 15 to 120 minutes.
It cannot tell you whether ChatGPT names you more this month than last; a tracker can. So pair them: a tracker or a free monthly check for the score, work on the sources for the change, and the same prompt panel every month to see whether one moves the other. Ahrefs found Reddit mentions correlate with AI visibility (0.75 across 10,000 brands) but "can't say mentions cause AI visibility", so judge the pairing on your own panel, not on a promise.
Trackers and Octosift do different jobs
What each kind of tool covers. Use one of each, or a tracker and your own team.
| What is compared | AI visibility trackers | Octosift |
|---|---|---|
| Measures how often AI names you | Yes | No |
| Compares you with competitors | Yes | No |
| Shows which sources AI cites | Yes, most of them | Reddit threads only |
| Helps with your own site content | Some: Profound, Scrunch, AthenaHQ, Goodie | No |
| Finds the Reddit threads cited for buyer questions | Ahrefs tracks Reddit as a source | Yes |
| Answers in those threads | No | Yes, from your own accounts |
06How can you check your AI visibility for free?
You can check your AI visibility for free by asking the assistants your buyers' questions yourself and counting who is named and which sources are cited; free tiers, trials and our own free check save you some of the typing.
Free options among the nine: AthenaHQ's Essential tier (300 credits), Profound's trial (50 prompts run daily for 7 days), Ahrefs' free AI visibility check, and 7-day trials from Scrunch, LLMrefs and Goodie. Our free AI visibility check, linked under Read next, gives you buyer questions for your category, opens each one in ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity or Google AI Mode with the question filled in, and turns what you see into a score. It runs in your browser, with no sign-up.
To do it entirely by hand:
- 1Write 10 buyer questionsUnbranded and in your buyers' words, like "best CRM for a five-person sales team" or "best running shoes for flat feet under $150".
- 2Ask four or five assistantsChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini or Google AI Mode, and Claude, with web search on and a fresh chat each time.
- 3Record three thingsWhether you are named, whether you are recommended for this buyer, and the sources listed under the answer.
- 4Repeat on another dayAnswers vary between runs. Two runs on two days tell you far more than one.
- 5Do it again next monthSame questions, same assistants. The change from month to month is the number that matters.
07How to choose an AI visibility tool
Choose by three things in this order: the assistants your buyers use, the number of questions you need to track, and whether you want data only or also an agent that drafts changes.
- Check the engines on the plan you will buy. Peec AI's Starter covers 3 models you choose, Otterly.AI's Lite 4 of 7, Scrunch's Core 4, and Semrush's prompt tracking covers Google AI Mode and ChatGPT.
- Count prompts honestly. Ten buyer questions in three wordings is 30 prompts before you add competitors or countries.
- Ask how often each prompt runs and whether it runs more than once. Answers vary between runs.
- Look for a sources view: which pages and Reddit threads are cited, not only a score.
- Make sure you can export the raw answers, so you can check the score yourself.
- Use the trial on your real questions. Semrush has no trial; most of the others do.
- Treat case-study percentages as marketing. On the vendor pages we read, most give no method.
08Do AI visibility tools improve your rankings in AI answers?
No, not by themselves: a tracker shows where you stand, and any change comes from work on your own pages and on the sources AI cites.
What a tracker does give you is a baseline, and that matters because the assistants change on their own. In Meltwater's October 2026 data (about 120,000 prompts, 12.7 million answers, eight platforms), Gemini's answers went from about 9.8 links to about 3.7 from October 15, and its total citations dropped 66%. Without a before and after, you would not know whether a drop was yours or Gemini's.
Be careful with cause in both directions. Ahrefs found Reddit mentions track AI visibility at 0.75 across 10,000 brands and 260 million prompts, the strongest factor it measured, and still writes "We can't say mentions cause AI visibility." A tool that shows your score rising after a change has shown timing, not proof.
Questions people ask
What is AI visibility?
AI visibility is how often, and how well, AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google's AI Overviews name your brand when people ask about your category, and which sources they cite when they do. Tools measure it by running a fixed set of prompts and counting mentions, positions and sources.
Which AI visibility tool is cheapest?
Of the nine, Otterly.AI lists the lowest paid plan: Lite at EUR 29 a month for 16 prompts on 4 of 7 engines, in a November 17, 2026 capture of its pricing page. Ahrefs Brand Radar custom prompts start at $50 a month, and LLMrefs is $79 for 500 prompts, marked limited time. AthenaHQ's Essential tier is free.
Is there a free AI visibility checker?
Yes. Ahrefs offers a free AI visibility check, AthenaHQ has a free tier, and Profound's trial runs 50 prompts daily for 7 days. Our free AI visibility check gives you buyer questions for your category and scores who gets named, with no sign-up. You can also ask the assistants by hand.
Do AI visibility tools improve rankings?
No. They measure where you appear and which sources are cited. Your place in AI answers changes only when what the assistants read changes: your own pages, independent coverage, and the threads and reviews they cite. Some tools draft fixes, which you still have to publish.
What is the difference between AI visibility, GEO and AEO?
AI visibility is the measurement. GEO (generative engine optimization) and AEO (answer engine optimization) are two names for the work of improving it, and vendors use them loosely: some lead with AEO, others with GEO.
Which AI assistants should I track?
The ones your buyers use. Most tools cover ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google's AI Overviews. Claude is listed by Otterly.AI, AthenaHQ's Starter plan, LLMrefs and Ahrefs' Index plan, but not by Scrunch's Core plan or Semrush's prompt tracking.
Does any AI visibility tool post on Reddit?
None of the nine pages we read describes posting replies on Reddit. Ahrefs Brand Radar tracks Reddit as a source, and a Peec AI mock-up suggests joining a subreddit discussion. Octosift does the Reddit part, finding and answering cited threads, and does not measure share of voice.
How often should I check AI visibility?
Monthly is a sensible minimum, with the same prompts each time and several runs per prompt, because answers vary between runs. Assistants also change their sources on their own: Meltwater saw Gemini's Reddit citations fall 88% between the first and second halves of October 2026.
Sources
- 1.Profound pricing, Profound. Read November 18, 2026.
- 2.Peec AI pricing, Peec AI. Read November 18, 2026.
- 3.Otterly.AI pricing (capture of 17 November 2026), Otterly.AI. Read November 17, 2026.
- 4.Scrunch pricing, Scrunch. Read November 18, 2026.
- 5.AthenaHQ pricing, AthenaHQ. Read November 18, 2026.
- 6.AI Visibility Toolkit (Knowledge Base), Semrush. Read November 18, 2026.
- 7.Brand Radar, Ahrefs. Read November 18, 2026.
- 8.LLMrefs pricing, LLMrefs. Read November 18, 2026.
- 9.Goodie pricing, Goodie. Read November 18, 2026.
- 10.Top domains cited by AI search: Analysis based on 30M sources, Peec AI. Read November 18, 2026.
- 11.Which Types of Mentions Correlate the Strongest With AI Visibility? (260M AI Prompts Analyzed), Ahrefs. Read November 18, 2026.
- 12.AI search visibility report for October 2026: Gemini pulls back from Reddit and Perplexity trims its sources, Meltwater. Read November 18, 2026.


